Church Newsroom, Approaching Latter-day Saint Doctrine
4 May 2007, paragraphs on authoritative doctrine and isolated statements
Explains how the Church identifies its doctrine and how much weight to give an individual leader’s statement.
Latter-day Saint history
Eternal progression in
Latter-day Saint teaching.
A question about God’s past, humanity’s future, and a debate that connects them.
The words behind the question
“As man now is,
God once was:
As God now is,
man may be.”
Lorenzo Snow’s couplet
Recorded in his 1884 biography.
Explore the documentary trail
The historical answer
Yes, if the question is historical: Joseph Smith taught in Nauvoo that God the Father had lived on an earth as a man. Notes by several people who heard the April 1844 sermon preserve that teaching in different words. The first printed version appeared that August. The familiar polished version is later, but its central claim is already in the earlier records. S13 S15 S16 S17 S18 S19 S20 S21
The answer changes if the question is what the Church asks people to believe about the Father's entire past. Its Gospel Topics essay acknowledges the tradition and says little has been revealed about that part of Lorenzo Snow's couplet. Its General Handbook teaches the other half, human exaltation through Jesus Christ, as part of God's stated purpose. Neither source gives the Father a complete mortal biography. S27 S49 S53
The Father's past Did a founding prophet teach that the Father had lived as a man? Yes. This goes beyond saying the Father has a body today or that Jesus lived in Galilee. S05 S15 S16 S17 S64
Humanity's future Can women and men become like their Heavenly Parents through Christ? This is a scriptural and current Church teaching. Its scriptural basis does not depend on proving where the Father lived. S03 S04 S06 S49 S53 S82
God's present growth Does an exalted Father keep learning previously unknown truths? Latter-day Saint leaders have given incompatible answers. Growth in dominion, posterity, or glory is a distinct claim. S33 S37 S41 S42 S43 S73 S74
Verification here establishes what a document says, when it was made, what kind of authority it has, and what can fairly be inferred from it. Whether it describes divine reality is a theological judgment that historical records cannot independently test.
The usual term for this subject is eternal progression. The word progression needs an object: who progresses, and in what respect? Snow's two-part saying connects God's past with human destiny. Young, Woodruff, Pratt, and later writers also argued about God's activity now. Those are related questions with different evidence. S26 S27 S33 S37 S42 S73
Embodiment Doctrine and Covenants 130:22 describes the Father and Son as having tangible bodies, while distinguishing the Holy Ghost. The verse states what kind of being the Father is. It does not describe how or when he came to possess that body. S05
Exaltation In the Church's usage this is eternal life with God and becoming like him through Christ. Resurrection or immortality alone does not mean that everyone receives exaltation. Scripture, the handbook, and instructional material connect exaltation with grace, covenants, and enduring faithfulness. S03 S04 S06 S09 S48 S49 S53
Mortality A mortal life, a previous lack of godhood, personal sin, and a need to repent are four different assertions. Smith offered a comparison to Jesus. The Church teaches that Jesus was divine before Bethlehem and lived without sin. Mortality therefore cannot, by itself, establish that the Father had sinned. S11 S15 S16 S20 S64
Increase An omniscient being might be said to increase in creations, posterity, or dominion without discovering a previously unknown fact. Other nineteenth-century speakers explicitly included knowledge among the things that increase. Translating both views into the single word progression hides their disagreement. S33 S37 S42 S43 S73 S74
Here God means the Father unless the text specifies Jesus Christ, another divine figure, or the Godhead. In the restoration movement as a whole, the word Mormon cannot identify one theology. Even within the Utah church, a signed First Presidency statement, an apostle's letter, and an individual believer's compilation answer different historical questions. S01 S40 S59 S64 S67 S74
God's eternity Doctrine and Covenants 20:17–19 describes the eternal, unchangeable God whom believers should worship. Moroni 8:18 makes a sweeping claim about God's constancy in an argument against infant baptism. Moses 1:3, 6 connects divine eternity and knowledge. These texts are evidence that a theory of God's development has to explain, not verses to omit. S07 S08 S09
The Son's growth Doctrine and Covenants 93:12–20 says the Son advanced from grace to grace and that disciples may receive of his fulness. Verses 26–29 discuss truth and uncreated intelligence. This section offers a pattern of growth without narrating the Father's analogous infancy, ordinances, or heavenly parentage. S04
Human exaltation Doctrine and Covenants 76:55–59 applies the word gods to recipients of celestial glory; verse 69 attributes their perfection to Jesus. Section 132:19–24 places that prospect in the setting of an eternal marriage covenant and continuing increase; verse 37 uses Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob as examples. These texts say much more directly what humans may become than how the Father became God. S03 S06
God's body and cosmos Section 130:18–22 joins the value of acquired intelligence with a statement about divine embodiment. Abraham 3:18–19 describes the eternity and difference of intelligences and God's superiority. In verses 2–3, Kolob is near God's throne. The passage does not identify Kolob as the Father's place of birth or former mortal home. S05 S10
The New Testament Romans 8:16–17 speaks of joint heirs with Christ; 2 Peter 1:4 of participation in the divine nature; 1 John 3:1–3 of future likeness; Revelation 3:21 of sharing Christ's throne. John 5:19–26 describes the Son acting after the Father's example and receiving life in himself. None explicitly recounts a previous mortal life of the Father. Smith's use of John 5 adds an interpretive step. S11 S15 S20 S78 S79 S80 S81
The early record does not open with a ready-made account of God's former life. The revelations now in sections 76 and 93, dated 1832 and 1833, supply strong language about human glory and Christ's fulness. Neither says the Father lived as a mortal on a previous earth. Reading the later sermon into every earlier text makes the history appear more uniform than it was. S03 S04 S13
Lecture 5 of the Lectures on Faith, published in the 1835 Doctrine and Covenants, calls the Father a personage of spirit and treats the Son as a personage of tabernacle. Section 130, dated 1843, explicitly gives a body to the Father as well. How readers reconcile the terms is a question of interpretation. The Church's historical account reports uncertainty about authorship, the probable role of Sidney Rigdon, and removal of the lectures from the 1921 edition. It is unsafe to call every line a dictated revelation personally written by Joseph Smith. S05 S24 S25
A particularly important bridge is the discourse dated January 30, 1842. A record in Wilford Woodruff's Book of Revelations represents Smith as teaching that the Father had redeemed a world and as relating that example to Jesus and the Saints. The Joseph Smith Papers editors explain that Woodruff was away and likely copied another person's notes. This makes it valuable evidence of an early teaching, but it is not a second personal eyewitness account by Woodruff. S12
By July 1843 section 132 gave explicit scriptural expression to human godhood and continuing family increase. By April 1844 we have multiple sermon reports explicitly describing the Father's earlier earthly life. These two dates mark different evidentiary thresholds: a text about human destiny and a well-attested public statement about the Father's past. S06 S13 S15 S16 S17
The date of an event and the date and nature of its surviving evidence are separate matters. This matters particularly for the 1842 notes and for Snow's much later recollection of an experience dated to 1840. S12 S26 S27 S84
Speaking at a Nauvoo general conference after the death of King Follett, Joseph Smith addressed the character of God and what death meant for the Saints. The Joseph Smith Papers distinguishes four principal contemporary reports. They are separate records of a single address, not four later church votes, and none is a verbatim stenographic transcript. The editors discuss differences in when and how the notes were made. S13 S14
“God himself the father of us all dwelt on a Earth same as J C himself did” S15
“he was once as one of us and was on a planet as Jesus was in the flesh” S16
“he once was man like us and the Father was once on an earth like us” S17
“refute the Idea that God was God from all eternity” S18
Bullock, Clayton, and Woodruff agree on a past life comparable to Jesus's earthly life. Richards preserves a different piece of the argument: a challenge to the idea that God had always been God. Agreement on the first point is especially strong because the reporters phrase it differently. Richards's words matter because a body alone would not establish a change of divine status. S15 S16 S17 S18
The sermon also taught that humans could learn to become gods and consoled listeners about the dead. The analogy between Father, Son, and Saints is central to its reasoning. It is fair to say Smith taught a former earthly life; it is a further step to claim that all details of Jesus's life, or of an ordinary believer's life, repeat the Father's experience. S13 S15 S16 S20
The Times and Seasons printed the sermon on August 15, 1844, after Smith's death, using a text prepared from Bullock and Clayton. Pages 613–614 are a good early printed citation. A separate, fuller manuscript-history version, compiled in the 1850s, is the source of polished wording widely quoted since. Modern teaching manuals make that wording easy to find. A later editorial sentence is a legitimate quotation when identified as such. In that manuscript history the wording is: “God himself was once as we are now, and is an exalted man, and sits enthroned in yonder heavens!” S13 S19 S20 S21 S83
This chain matters in both directions. The edited version cannot establish that every word is exactly as spoken. But its late date cannot explain away a doctrine stated by the earlier reporters. Manuscript quotations need a reporter and page; published and composite versions need to be identified as such. S13 S15 S16 S17 S18 S19 S20 S21
Before either the August printing or the later composite, dissenters included a resolution against a plurality of gods above the God of this universe in the Nauvoo Expositor on June 7, 1844. This independently dates public controversy over a plurality of higher gods. A hostile resolution is good evidence of what its authors opposed, but it is not a transcript of what Smith said or a guarantee that every accusation was accurate. S71
On June 16, 1844, Smith returned to plurality and divine parentage in the sermon often called the Sermon in the Grove. Bullock's notes report an argument that if Jesus had a Father, the Father also had a Father. The Joseph Smith Papers documents Smith's use of the King James wording of Revelation 1:6 and a difference from his earlier Bible revision. Readers should distinguish Smith's interpretation from what this verse explicitly says in other readings. S22 S23
There is evidence here for divine ancestry in Smith's public preaching. It does not settle whether he specified an actually infinite series, a first ancestor, an exact world and calendar, or identical histories for each divine parent. Those are additional models. Treating their logic as a separate question preserves how striking the explicit teaching already was. S20 S22 S23 S49
“As man now is, God once was: As God now is, man may be.” S27 S87
The two clauses point in opposite directions in time. The first asserts something about the Father's past; the second describes a human possibility. It is possible to stress the second, as contemporary Church materials do, without turning the first into a late invention. The best case does not rest on one recollection. S26 S27 S49 S72 S84
1840, as later remembered The 1884 Biography and Family Record compiled by Eliza R. Snow Smith presents Lorenzo's account of receiving the insight in 1840. Cite it as a later account assigning the experience to 1840. The story's event date is not the date of a surviving 1840 diary entry. A facsimile of the printed page allows the transcription to be checked. S26 S87
The reported endorsement A later family account says Joseph Smith recognized Snow's principle as true or revelatory. The Church student manual relays a return-from-England narrative through LeRoi C. Snow's 1919 article. Its January 1843 return chronology conflicts with evidence that Snow left Liverpool in January and reached Nauvoo in April. Richards recorded his arrival on April 12. That corrects the proposed timing without proving or disproving the private conversation. S27 S28 S29 S30
October 11, 1857 Snow publicly described the Father's exaltation as the outcome of continued progression. The sermon report was printed during his lifetime and is stronger evidence for what he publicly taught than a twentieth-century recollection about a private exchange. Compare the period sermon with the modern manual's treatment. S27 S72
January 11, 1892 A poem in Snow's record book restates the parallel and places it in the setting of Christ and human purification. It is independent evidence that Snow continued to own the idea late in life. It is not an independent, contemporary report of what happened to him in 1840. S84
On June 22, 1851, Wilford Woodruff recorded Brigham Young speaking about the Father experiencing earthly ordeals, in connection with what humans experience. The journal is Woodruff's record of Young. It should be labeled with both names. In an 1857 published discourse, Young said: “He has been earthly, and is of precisely the same species of being that we are.” The surrounding discussion moves into divine genealogy and Adam. A quotation isolated from those paragraphs can conceal how Young developed the idea. S31 S32
Orson Hyde, an apostle, used a more tentative register in October 1853. In discussing divine development he imagined that God might once have been a child, using the qualifier “perhaps.” Hyde's reasoning shows the possibilities some early leaders entertained. His qualification matters: an illustrative possibility is not a revelation about the Father's childhood. S77
On December 6, 1857, Woodruff himself preached that God increases in knowledge, power, and dominion. The December 16 Deseret News report and the Journal of Discourses preserve the point, with a small variation in wording. Compare the two as printed reports of the same address. This is stronger evidence for his position than inferring it from a single reference to increase in glory. S36 S37 S76
In The Mediation and Atonement (1882), John Taylor, then Church President, described human advancement toward godhood through the atonement and obedience. A Church teaching manual reproduces the passage and specifies the book pages. Taylor gives strong evidence about human destiny. The cited passage does not by itself supply a detailed biography of the Father. S38 S39
In its 1909 statement The Origin of Man, the First Presidency taught humanity’s divine parentage and potential. Of the Father it said, “God Himself is an exalted man, perfected, enthroned, and supreme.” That makes the text unusually strong evidence for how the institutional leadership characterized God and humans. The statement speaks of God's present condition without specifying the time, place, or sequence of his exaltation. S40
1852 and 1853: opposing arguments An unsigned Millennial Star essay reprinted from the Deseret News treated God's development from manhood as an argument for continuing progression in intelligence. In The Seer of August 1853, Orson Pratt wrote: “The Father and the Son do not progress in knowledge and wisdom”. For Pratt the reason was that they already know all things. The split was present within early Utah Mormonism. S73 S89
The First Presidency and Pratt A First Presidency statement dated July 25, 1860 and reprinted in 1865 rejected a group of positions attributed to Pratt, including the limit he placed on divine increase in knowledge. Read the whole document: it also deals with intelligence, particles, and Pratt's published speculations. A rebuke of several propositions in that setting cannot substitute for a current institutional definition of omniscience. S41 S73
Woodruff and Young In 1857 Woodruff said, “God himself is increasing and progressing in knowledge, power and dominion”. Young on January 13, 1867 challenged the claim that God could not progress in knowledge, wisdom, or understanding. The original printed Journal of Discourses 11:286 confirms the language and the 1867 date. This is different from saying only that more kingdoms or creations can be added. S33 S34 S35 S37 S76
Joseph Fielding Smith and Bruce R. McConkie In 1971 President Joseph Fielding Smith held that God is complete in knowledge and power yet increases as his kingdoms and dominions multiply. In a 1980 BYU address and a separate general conference talk, apostle Bruce R. McConkie rejected the idea that God is learning new truths. These are direct counterexamples to the claim of historical unanimity. S42 S43 S75
A candid private letter In a letter dated February 19, 1981, McConkie addressed Eugene England about Young's teachings. He recognized conflicting statements attributed to Young and gave priority to the position he understood scripture to teach. This document sets out McConkie's own way of resolving the conflict. It was addressed to England, not to Kraut, and it was not a joint First Presidency statement. S59 S74
One reconciliation distinguishes existing eternally from holding the station of God eternally. That distinction would allow an eternal intelligence to have a history of development. It draws on the language of intelligence in Doctrine and Covenants 93 and Abraham 3 and the reported sermon in which Smith disputed eternal godhood. It is a reading of these sources together. Neither scripture explicitly defines a date at which our Father assumed his station. S04 S07 S08 S10 S18 S20
Another reading starts with scripture's description of God as unchangeable and all-knowing. It can interpret eternal increase as a growth in the extent of God's work or in the number of his exalted children. Joseph Fielding Smith made this distinction explicitly. It accounts well for his text and McConkie's addresses, but it does not reproduce the ordinary meaning of Woodruff's 1857 statement or Young's 1867 objection. S07 S08 S09 S33 S37 S42 S43 S75
A third approach considers perfection and continuing progress complementary. Eugene England presented an argument of this sort in BYU Studies, distinguishing kinds or spheres of perfection. His article is a named theologian's constructive proposal. An argument for compatibility should be labeled as an argument; citing it does not establish that the historical speakers intended the same reconciliation. S44 S74 S85
Matthew Bowman's historical study follows the dispute through later writers, including B. H. Roberts and John A. Widtsoe. It is useful for finding debates that were not confined to Young's lifetime. One date in its note 19 illustrates why the original still matters: compare the sermon heading for Young's January address. The Journal of Discourses volume dates it to 1867. S33 S34 S44
The fairest unresolved question is narrower than whether God is perfect: does perfect divine knowledge admit any acquisition of previously unknown truth? Report where leaders answered yes and where others answered no. Neither the existence of conflicting answers nor a scholar's explanation proves that the current Church treats every answer as equally authoritative. S01 S37 S41 S42 S43 S49 S53 S73 S74
In October 1976, President Spencer W. Kimball expressly rejected the Adam-God theory. In April 1977, in another general conference address, he invoked Snow's couplet and spoke of humanity's godly potential, including creative work. Those two addresses are a useful control on interpretation. A president could reject a particular identification of Adam and still speak affirmatively of the broader Father-to-human parallel. S45 S65
In a 1982 Ensign question-and-answer column, Gerald N. Lund considered whether Snow's statement was accepted Church teaching. He affirmed its acceptance while distinguishing that assessment from a specific official First Presidency declaration on the couplet. This is evidence about its reception in Church teaching media. Lund wrote in his capacity at that time; the column is not an addition to scripture. S01 S46
Two 1997 interviews with President Gordon B. Hinckley are often merged. In the San Francisco Chronicle interview he initially resisted the reporter's formulation, then discussed Snow's saying and distinguished the Father's past from human progression. TIME separately quoted a guarded answer about whether the first idea is taught or emphasized. These are different interviews with different questions and edited presentations. Neither text supports a simple claim that Hinckley formally rescinded the sermon. S54 S55
At the October 1997 general conference Hinckley addressed the impression some members had formed from media interviews. He affirmed his grasp of Church doctrine. He did not identify a particular disputed quotation or issue a new account of the Father's prior life. This speech can contextualize both interviews; it cannot be used as a line-by-line correction to either one. S54 S55 S56
A Church manual on Brigham Young published in 1997 included the idea that the Father once lived on another planet. In chapter 4 that phrasing appears in editorial introductory prose before the selections from Young. Labeling it as the manual's wording, with the chapter citation, avoids putting its sentence in Young's mouth. S32 S47
“Little has been revealed about the first half of this couplet, and consequently little is taught.” S49
The essay, originally published in February 2014, is the clearest institutional framing of the question. It discusses Smith and Snow alongside scriptural and early Christian material. Its notes identify the King Follett discourse's status outside canon. It gives sustained attention to becoming like God through Christ and offers no comparable account of the Father's mortal career. Little taught is a statement about the extent of teaching, not a denial that it has ever been taught. S13 S49 S50
Church materials illustrate the distinction. Gospel Principles teaches that the Father desires his children's exaltation; the Joseph Smith manual republishes the polished King Follett language. An institute New Testament manual even quotes Smith's reasoning about the Father's Father. These are evidence of what students could encounter in Church curriculum. They do not supply three independent witnesses to an 1844 event. S21 S22 S47 S48 S52 S83
After the essay, Seventy Larry R. Lawrence wrote explicitly in the March 2016 Ensign that Heavenly Father had been a mortal man who progressed to a fulness of light. The date rules out the claim that the idea vanished from all Church publications after 2014. The author, genre, and authority matter: a named Seventy's magazine article and a collective definition of binding doctrine are different things. A 1995 joint proclamation and Dallin H. Oaks’s 2023 conference address likewise connect divine destiny, family, and exaltation. S01 S49 S51 S94 S95
For a current summary of human destiny, cite the General Handbook, section 1. It centers Jesus Christ and distinguishes immortality from eternal life or exaltation; it places family relationships and covenants in that framework. The Church's essay on Heavenly Mother includes daughters as well as sons in a teaching about Heavenly Parents. The available statements do not authorize filling out an imagined biography of Heavenly Mother by analogy. S48 S49 S53 S82
Use the Church's own explanation of how doctrine is established and its history topic on the Journal of Discourses. The latter is historically valuable, but its published sermons are not all official doctrinal statements. An early sermon, a current handbook, and a newspaper interview can all be authentic while answering quite different questions. S01 S02 S33 S53 S54
Kraut is valuable in two ways: he preserved leads to difficult historical texts, and he left a direct record of how an independent Mormon writer understood them. Each quotation needs two attributions: the writer who used it and the earlier person or text to which it is ascribed. Eight relevant works or collections from the catalog were examined in the supplied research. S57 S58 S59 S60 S61 S62 S63 S88 S90
The Only True God and Mysteries of Creation The first work (winter 1988), chapter 11, sections 5–8, builds a connected argument from God's former manhood to the destiny of humans. Kraut goes further when he extends mortal ordinances to the Father's own history. The second work (December 1989), especially chapters 9 and 12, develops his account of divine identities and the plurality of gods. Compare each inference with what the 1844 sources actually say. S15 S20 S22 S58 S60
Pre-Existence and Reincarnation The 1985 compilation says its excerpts are selected by subject. For its Young quotation compare the full Journal of Discourses paragraph. Reincarnation (February 1994), chapter 20, distinguishes ordinary repeated mortal births, which Kraut rejects, from his own proposed account of Adam and Eve, resurrection, and mortal posterity. It is inaccurate to collapse these two models or to call Kraut's proposal a contemporary Church teaching. S32 S61 S63 S64 S65
Michael/Adam and Letters and Responses Michael/Adam specifically defends the disputed identification and acknowledges contemporary rejection. Letters and Responses includes Kraut's October 26, 1980 letter to McConkie; its comparison of Young with McConkie is testable from each man's text. Kraut's assertion about whom McConkie had in mind is an inference. The separate letter to England provides McConkie's own later discussion of Young. S33 S43 S59 S65 S74 S90
Sermons and Writings, volumes 2 and 3 These compilations provide two especially useful tests. Volume 2 can be checked against Woodruff's June 1851 journal. Volume 3 reprints a newspaper essay that can be checked against the Millennial Star. The next section gives the results and explains why each changes how the passage should be quoted. S31 S62 S88 S89
1. Young via Woodruff, June 22, 1851 Volume 2 of Kraut's Sermons and Writings attributes an address to Young as reported by Woodruff. Compare pages 45–46 with Woodruff's journal, page 325. Woodruff's version includes the words “& the fall”; those words are missing in Kraut's rendering of the passage. Cite the journal for its exact wording. The difference alone does not establish why it arose. S31 S62
2. The unsigned 1852 essay Kraut's volume 3 points to “Knowledge” in the Millennial Star, vol. 14, no. 25, August 14, 1852. The original, pp. 385–387, identifies it as a reprint from the Deseret News. Page 386 says God “from manhood, by continual progression, became God.” The writer links divine knowledge and progression directly. There is no byline identifying a prophet. Attribute it to the unsigned essay and link the scanned page. S88 S89 S91
3. Young versus McConkie Kraut's October 1980 comparison does identify a real difference. Young's reported words on printed page 286 challenge the limitation on God's learning. McConkie's June 1980 BYU address rejects a God who is still discovering truths. Young's January sermon actually dates to 1867. These facts survive independent of Kraut's explanation of McConkie's intent. S33 S34 S43 S44 S59
4. Do the ordinances follow? Kraut connects the Father's manhood with ordinances he thinks that manhood entailed. Scripture explains ordinances and covenants for the Saints, and the April sermon teaches a comparison between the lives of the Father and the Son. The identified texts do not name the Father's baptizer, identify a spouse in a previous life, or document a sequence of saving ordinances he received. Label the extension as Kraut's reasoning. S04 S06 S15 S16 S20 S58
Source rule: give Kraut credit when his compilation leads to the text. Credit the original witness or publication for what it records. Retain both links when presenting a variant, and distinguish textual disagreement from disagreement about doctrine. S31 S33 S43 S59 S62 S88 S89
Christian belief in the incarnation concerns Jesus Christ. Smith's 1844 argument explicitly concerned the Father as well. Latter-day Saint teaching identifies Jesus as the premortal Jehovah who created under the Father's direction. In this historical controversy, identifying God the Father explicitly avoids confusion. A joint 1916 exposition explains why scripture can also call Jesus “Father” in several senses while distinguishing him from Elohim. S11 S15 S16 S17 S64 S93
The records under review do not establish that he sinned, name his redeemer, or document how anyone atoned for him. An 1842 report actually describes the Father as redeeming a world. The 1844 parallel with Jesus makes a simple inference from mortality to personal sin especially weak. A claim that the Father acted as a redeemer and a claim that he needed redemption are distinct. S12 S15 S16 S18 S20 S64
Young's April 9, 1852 sermon identifies Adam as father and God in a striking passage; Kraut defended a reading of it. In 1976 Kimball specifically rejected the Adam-God theory. That rejection does not erase Smith's separate claim that the Father lived as a man on an earth, nor does the King Follett sermon by itself establish Young's identification of Adam. S15 S17 S45 S65 S90 S92
The Church's FAQ rejects that slogan and affirms becoming like God. Christian discipleship, relationship with the Father, and participation in divine life are central in its essay. Historical leaders, including Kimball, did speak about creation and worlds. A fair account can acknowledge that language without converting it into a promise assigning every exalted person an individual planet. S45 S49 S53 S66
Smith preached that the Father had a Father, but the cited sermon does not supply that being's personal name or a location for the Father's former earthly life. Abraham identifies Kolob in relation to God's throne, not as that world. The sources support a claim about ancestry more directly than a specific celestial family tree or map. S10 S16 S22 S23 S52
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the Community of Christ, and independent Mormon writers should be named separately. The historical scope of the word Mormon is wider than the institutional scope of a statement by a Utah church president. Community of Christ's current Basic Beliefs affirm one living God as Trinity and identify Christ's humanity and divinity. That statement does not present Snow's couplet as a shared Restoration creed. S27 S49 S53 S57 S67
A similar distinction matters when comparing Christian traditions. Second Peter speaks of partaking of the divine nature. Catholic and Orthodox teaching both use participation in divine life to describe what Christ makes possible. The Catholic Catechism also identifies God as without origin or end; Orthodox catechesis places human participation within the life of the Trinity. Their teachings provide parallels to the second half of Snow's couplet without entailing the first. S68 S69 S70 S79
The Church's Becoming Like God essay itself draws on early Christian language about deification. This helps explain why a Latter-day Saint can see continuity between Scripture, early Christianity, and exaltation. It does not establish that the Christian writers intended Joseph Smith's account of the Father's past. Distinguish an analogy in religious language from agreement on the nature or history of God. S15 S49 S68 S69 S70 S79
What difference does this make to readers? Someone can accept becoming more like God while rejecting previous mortality for the Father. Someone else can affirm the Father's previous mortality while denying he is still learning. Both examples are documented. A single yes-or-no answer covering all three teachings would misrepresent people on more than one side of the debate. S42 S43 S49 S68 S69 S70 S73
For historical context on shifts in reception, Faulconer and Morrison ask how the King Follett discourse could remain widely known while parts of it carried different weight for different generations of Saints. Their essay and Bowman's study are useful guides to interpretation. They belong alongside, rather than in place of, the sermon notes and named writers whose ideas they interpret. S13 S15 S22 S44 S86
The following describes the verification reported in the supplied research, dated November 18, 2026. These notes and their access limitations are retained from that report.
Manuscript versus printed witness The four King Follett manuscript pages were compared across reporters, with the Woodruff page also checked against the manuscript image. The August 1844 pages and the later manuscript-history wording were separately identified. Counting those printed versions as additional eyewitnesses would inflate the evidence. S13 S14 S15 S16 S17 S18 S19 S20 S21
A date and a source chain Snow's travel was checked against the Joseph Smith Papers introduction and journal. The year of Young's January sermon was checked against the volume heading and printed page. For Woodruff's 1857 statement, both the newspaper record and the Journal of Discourses version were consulted. The wording can vary without the reports becoming evidence of two different occasions. S28 S29 S30 S33 S34 S35 S36 S37 S76
A periodical traced to an earlier printing Kraut's “Knowledge” matches the August 1852 Millennial Star reprint. The corresponding February 7 Deseret News text appears under the heading “To the Saints,” p. 26. The chain links one argument across two periodicals and one later compilation. It verifies publication and content, not the identity of the unsigned writer. S88 S89 S91
A disputed viewpoint checked against its proponent Pratt's 1853 discussion was checked in The Seer, p. 117, with surrounding numbered paragraphs; the First Presidency's objection was checked separately. McConkie's addresses and the scan of his February 1981 signed letter were distinguished from later accounts and from Kraut's 1980 letter. These checks keep a critic's paraphrase from replacing the author's own claim. S41 S43 S59 S73 S74 S75
Limits of access and scope For Taylor's 1882 book the indexed digitization was checked against the Church manual quotation and its print-page attribution; full-text access was intermittent. Later recollections were identified as such. This is a substantial selected corpus, not a claim to have searched every surviving diary or every branch's archives. An unverified detail is identified as unestablished in these sources, not disproved. S26 S28 S38 S39 S57 S67
Follow the evidence
95 sources, with the document type, the precise passage, and a note on what each establishes. Select a citation in the article to come directly to its entry.
Showing all 95 sources
4 May 2007, paragraphs on authoritative doctrine and isolated statements
Explains how the Church identifies its doctrine and how much weight to give an individual leader’s statement.
Gospel Topics, entry on the nineteenth-century sermon collection
Describes the collection’s unofficial status, the reporters’ methods, and the possibility of transcription errors.
Vision of Joseph Smith and Sidney Rigdon, 16 February 1832, verses 50–60, especially 58–59
Calls the celestial heirs gods and describes their relationship to Christ and the Father.
Revelation of 6 May 1833, verses 12–20, 26–36
Describes Christ receiving a fulness, the promise to his followers, and the eternity of intelligence. The account of growth here concerns Christ.
Instruction of 2 April 1843, verses 18–22
Verses 18–19 connect knowledge gained here with resurrection. Verse 22 describes the present bodies of the Father and the Son.
Revelation recorded 12 July 1843, verses 19–24
Places the promise of godhood, a continuing posterity, and exaltation within the covenant described in the passage.
Articles and Covenants, 1830, verses 17–19
Describes God as infinite, eternal, and unchangeable. This passage frames a question that later sermons about divine progression must address.
Verse 18, in Mormon’s letter to Moroni, first published 1830
Affirms the unchangeableness of God within an argument about the salvation of little children.
Verses 3–4, 33–39, revelation dated June 1830
Connects worlds without number with God’s work and glory in bringing about human immortality and eternal life.
Verses 18–28, first published 1842
Describes intelligences, their differences, and premortal planning. Abraham’s reasoning about differences in intelligence recurs in Smith’s June sermon.
King James Version, verses 19–26
Jesus describes doing the Father’s works, giving life, and receiving life in himself. Smith drew further conclusions about the Father’s personal history in 1844.
Wilford Woodruff, Book of Revelations, pp. [3]–[4], especially [3]
Woodruff was away from Nauvoo and likely copied someone else’s notes. It is the only surviving detailed account of that sermon; Joseph Smith’s journal also has a brief entry.
Editorial guide to the 7 April 1844 discourse, four contemporaneous reports and the composite texts
Explains the reporters’ methods, the August 1844 publication, and Jonathan Grimshaw’s later compilation.
7 April 1844, general church minutes, pp. 14–22, historical introduction
Describes all six individual accounts, their dates, and their relationship to the published text. Distinguishes notes taken during the address from later copies.
7 April 1844, manuscript p. 16
Records the Father living on an earth as Jesus did and relates the comparison to bodily death and renewed life.
7 April 1844, manuscript p. 13
Describes God as having once been like the hearers and having lived on a planet as Jesus did in the flesh.
7 April 1844, journal vol. 5, p. [135]
Records the Father’s earlier earthly existence and a further increase in glory through the Son’s kingdom. The surviving journal appears to be a fair copy of Woodruff’s notes.
7 April 1844, Joseph Smith’s journal, book 4, p. [67]
Records Smith challenging the assumption that God was God from all eternity and discussing the Father’s power to lay down and resume his body.
15 August 1844, vol. 5, no. 15, p. 613, in a report spanning pp. 612–617
The first printed account combined Bullock and Clayton. This page describes the enthroned God in human form.
15 August 1844, vol. 5, no. 15, p. 614
The next page of the same report explicitly describes the Father’s life on an earth, the comparison with Jesus, and humans advancing toward godhood.
History, volume E-1, p. 1970, compiled 1855–1856, recounting 7 April 1844
Contains the familiar polished wording about an exalted man enthroned in heaven. The contemporary reports preserve the substance in different words.
Sermon on the plurality of gods, manuscript p. [3]
Records Smith’s reasoning that the Father of Jesus had a father, followed by a comparison of laying down and taking up life.
Thomas Bullock’s report, manuscript p. [1], editorial notes 1–2
Identifies Revelation 1:6 and explains how Smith’s earlier revision of the verse differed from the King James wording he used in the sermon.
Latter Day Saints’ Messenger and Advocate, May 1835, 1:122–124, especially p. 122
The early lecture describes the Father as a personage of spirit and the Son as a personage of tabernacle. The text helps date changing descriptions of divine embodiment.
Historical entry, sections on authorship, publication in 1835, and removal in 1921
Explains uncertainty about authorship and the relationship between the fifth lecture and the later teaching in Doctrine and Covenants 130.
Salt Lake City, Deseret News Company, 1884, chapter IX, pp. 46–47
Prints Lorenzo’s first-person recollection of an insight he dated to spring 1840 and gives both lines of the couplet. Publication followed the reported experience by about 44 years.
Chapter 5, The Grand Destiny of the Faithful, especially notes 1–4 and 9
Reproduces both halves of the couplet. The notes trace the 1840 recollection to the 1884 biography and the account of the Father’s progression to an 1857 newspaper.
2004 edition, chapter 5, pp. 75–92, passage on Snow’s revelation
Repeats the later family account of Joseph’s endorsement and places the meeting in January 1843 after Snow returned. The contemporary travel documents in S29 and S30 correct that date.
Circa 5 January 1843, Joseph Smith Papers, Documents 11, pp. 315–317, historical introduction
Uses travel records to date Snow’s departure from Liverpool to 16 January and his arrival in Nauvoo to 12 April 1843.
12 April 1843, book 2, pp. [114]–[115], linked page [115] and note 250
Willard Richards recorded the steamer’s arrival with the English Saints. The entry provides a contemporary check on later accounts of Snow’s return.
Journal entry for Sunday, 22 June 1851, Wilford Woodruff Papers
Records Young teaching about the Father’s earlier condition and probation, as well as human advancement to godhood. Compare Kraut’s later rendering at S62.
8 February 1857, reported by G. D. Watt, Journal of Discourses 4:215–221, especially p. 218
Describes the Father as previously living in the flesh and subsequently possessing an exalted body. The sermon also discusses Young’s ideas about Adam.
13 January 1867, reported by Edward L. Sloan, Journal of Discourses 11:282–291, especially p. 286
Young disputed Orson Pratt’s view of limits on divine knowledge and power. The text places the claim about God’s progress inside a sermon about learning.
Journal of Discourses, vol. 11, p. 286, original print facsimile
The original printed page verifies the wording of Young’s disagreement with Pratt, including its reference to knowledge and power.
Journal of Discourses, vol. 11, p. 286, Brigham Young University Scripture Citation Index
Provides a legible second rendering of the same page. Entries S33–S35 reproduce one sermon.
Deseret News, 16 December 1857, vol. 7, no. 41, p. 324, archival record D-247
The Wilford Woodruff Papers identifies the newspaper issue, printed pagination, and archival source for Woodruff’s sermon.
Deseret News, 16 December 1857, p. 324, second digital page of D-247
The transcription and underlying newspaper facsimile describe God’s continuing increase in knowledge, power, and dominion.
1882 edition, pp. 139–141, digital text in Project Gutenberg
The indexed primary text explains exaltation through Christ’s atonement. S39 confirms the passage and its print locator. Access to the full Gutenberg landing page was intermittent.
Chapter 1, The Origin and Destiny of Mankind, especially the section on Christ and note 7
Separately attributes Taylor’s teachings on divine potential and the need for Christ. Note 7 identifies The Mediation and Atonement, pp. 139–141.
Improvement Era, November 1909, pp. 75–81, reprinted in Ensign, February 2002, p. 26 onward
Describes humans as children of heavenly parents with divine potential. The Ensign identifies its standardization of spelling and punctuation.
Deseret News, 23 August 1865, passages on Orson Pratt and his publications
Objects to teachings in Pratt’s publications and addresses the authority to present doctrine for the Church. Read the named works and scope in context.
Ensign, May 1971, p. 2 onward
Presents the Father as omniscient and describes his attributes as complete. The author was President of the Church at publication.
Brigham Young University, 1 June 1980, section on the first heresy
Rejects an increase in God’s knowledge and describes divine increase in terms of kingdoms and dominions.
BYU Studies Quarterly 60, no. 3 (2021), article 6, beginning on p. 65
Reconstructs disagreements about God’s past and present progress. The essay supplies historical interpretation and references to the sources it discusses.
General conference, April 1977, passage citing Lorenzo Snow
Quotes both halves of a variant of Snow’s couplet while discussing human destiny and perfection.
Ensign, February 1982, pp. 39–40, I Have a Question
Lund argues that Church leaders’ use supports acceptance of Snow’s teaching. The article identifies its author and relies partly on a later family recollection.
1997, chapter 4, Knowing and Honoring the Godhead, pp. 28–35, editorial introduction and teachings
Both the collected teachings and a discussion question address the Father’s earlier experience as a man and his progression.
2009 edition, chapter 47, especially the closing discussion of the Father’s life
Describes human exaltation and quotes a later edited version of Smith’s explanation that the Father lived on an earth.
Essay on deification, especially the King Follett discourse and Lorenzo Snow sections
Affirms human divine potential and says little has been revealed regarding the first half of Snow’s couplet. The essay also explains how Latter-day Saints understand eternal worship of the Father.
23 October 2015, announcement describing the series of 13 Gospel Topics Essays
Explains how Church scholars prepared the essays and senior Church leaders reviewed them. Provides institutional context for S49.
Ensign, March 2016, pp. 64–68, introductory discussion of spiritual light
The author states that the Father was once mortal and describes gradual progress. Lawrence wrote as a member of the Seventy.
2018 edition, chapter 53, commentary on Revelation 1:6
The commentary quotes Smith’s teaching about the Father’s father and the polished King Follett wording about the exalted man.
Online edition, chapter 1, especially sections 1.1–1.3
Defines the Church’s contemporary teaching on salvation and exaltation and places it in the context of Christ, ordinances, and covenants.
San Francisco Chronicle, 13 April 1997, questions about God and eternal progression
Hinckley declined to elaborate on the Father’s past and explicitly affirmed eternal progression. Both question and answer are preserved.
TIME, 4 August 1997, p. 56, discussion of human divinity and the Father’s past
The reporter reproduces Hinckley’s qualified answer about teaching or emphasizing the Father’s former state, alongside an affirmation of human divine potential.
General conference, October 1997, passage discussing the recent media interviews
Hinckley addressed concerns about media impressions and affirmed that he understood Church doctrine. His remarks did not identify a specific disputed quotation.
Online catalog, entries for books, sermons, and letters
The user’s starting point identifies the relevant titles and leads to the digital texts in S58–S63.
Winter 1988, chapter 11, Doctrines of Deity, especially items 5–8, pp. 151–155
Kraut draws a connection between human and divine progression using earlier leaders’ statements. His citations to compilations can be traced to the underlying historical documents.
Seven Deadly Heresies, Part II, Did President Brigham Young Teach Deadly Heresies? A Letter to Bruce R. McConkie, October 26, 1980
Collects statements by other speakers alongside Kraut’s responses. McConkie’s BYU address at S43 supplies an independent text for the position Kraut disputes.
December 1989, chapter 9, The Only Begotten, p. 90 onward, and chapter 12, The Plurality of Gods, p. 117 onward
Kraut considers how different figures participate in creation and offers his own account of divine relationships. Compare the claims about Christ’s role with S64.
1985, preface, chapter 2 (p. 5 onward), and chapter 11 (p. 126 onward)
Kraut identifies Orson Pratt’s 1853 Seer as a major source and explains that the quotations are organized by topic. The preface documents Kraut’s selection method.
Compiled April 1994, entry for 22 June 1851, pp. 45–46
Reproduces a version of Young’s remarks with modernized punctuation and wording. Compare the original journal transcription at S31.
Pioneer Press, February 1994, chapters 19–20, especially pp. 179–191
The chapters compare reincarnation with Mormon teachings and discuss Adam separately. Useful for establishing Kraut’s own distinctions among mortality, resurrection, and repeated earthly lives.
1 January 2000, The Testimony of the Apostles, opening paragraphs
Identifies Jesus Christ as the premortal Jehovah and affirms that he created the earth under the direction of his Father.
General conference, October 1976, passage about the Adam-God theory
Kimball explicitly denounced the Adam-God theory. His statement identifies the specific teaching he was addressing.
Public FAQ, questions on becoming like God and on receiving a planet
Addresses popular descriptions of exaltation and explains the Church’s emphasis on following Christ and becoming like Heavenly Father.
Official current statement, Basic Beliefs, sections God and Jesus Christ
Identifies the Community of Christ’s Trinitarian confession and its account of Christ’s humanity and divinity.
Part 1, section 2, chapter 2, article 3, especially paragraphs 456–460 and 464–469
Explains participation in divine life through the incarnate Son. These paragraphs give the Catholic meaning of patristic language about humans becoming divine.
The Orthodox Faith, volume I, Doctrine and Scripture, section on the Holy Trinity
Describes becoming divine as participation through Christ and the Spirit in the life of the Trinity.
Part 1, section 2, chapter 1, article 1, especially paragraphs 200–202 and 212–213
Explains the Catholic confession of the one God and God’s enduring, unchanging life. Read with S68 for the setting of Catholic teaching about participation in divinity.
June 7, 1844, vol. 1, no. 1, p. [2], resolution 2
The second resolution objects to a plurality of gods above the God of this universe. The original issue documents the dissenters’ objection, not Smith’s exact words.
October 11, 1857, Journal of Discourses 5:312–317, especially p. 313
Snow explicitly relates the Father’s exaltation to continued progression. The sermon is direct evidence of what he publicly taught by 1857, regardless of uncertainty about the date of an earlier private conversation.
Vol. 1, no. 8, August 1853, p. 117, paragraphs 95–97, especially 96; PDF p. 125
The scanned printed page expressly distinguishes fullness of knowledge from other forms of increase. It confirms Pratt’s position without relying on the later denunciation.
February 19, 1981, especially letter pp. 6–7; date from letterhead
McConkie discusses Young and explains how he resolves conflicting statements. The file name suggests 1980; the dated letter itself establishes 1981. Not a response to Kraut.
General conference, October 1980, discussion of God attending a university to acquire truths
McConkie publicly rejects a God still discovering truths. This is a separate occasion from the June 1980 BYU address.
Journal of Discourses 6:115–121, especially p. 120
Agrees with the Deseret News report regarding continuing knowledge, power, and dominion, with a small wording difference. It is the same occasion as S36–S37.
October 6, 1853, Journal of Discourses 1:121–130, especially p. 123
Hyde speaks of the possibility that the Father was once a child. His qualifying word perhaps belongs with that claim.
King James Version, verses 16–17
Paul links being children of God with being heirs with Christ, in a passage also concerned with suffering and glorification.
King James Version, verses 3–4
The promise of participation in divine nature concerns human disciples. It does not narrate the Father’s prior state.
King James Version, verses 1–3
The text connects future likeness with the hope and purification of believers. It does not identify the Father’s former world.
King James Version, verse 21
The risen Christ promises a place with him on his throne, comparing it with his own overcoming and place with his Father.
Essay on the doctrine of heavenly parents, opening and concluding paragraphs
Describes women and men as beloved spirit children of Heavenly Parents and acknowledges the limited knowledge about Heavenly Mother.
Chapter 2, God the Eternal Father, pp. 36–44, especially p. 40
Publishes the familiar compiled rendering of the King Follett teaching about God as an exalted man; compare S15–S21 for the stages of transmission.
January 11, 1892, pp. 90–92; transcript in Within These Prison Walls
The dated poem restates Snow’s parallel in relation to Christ and purification. It supplies late lifetime evidence, not an 1840 memorandum.
BYU Studies 29, no. 3 (1989), article on divine perfection and continuing progression
England offers his own reconciliation of perfection and progress. The published article and the 1981 letter he received are separate documents.
BYU Studies 60, no. 3 (2021), beginning p. 85, Historical Background and discussion of reception
Traces the variable authority and influence assigned to the sermon and distinguishes it from the June 1844 sermon.
Deseret News Company, 1884, p. 46; monochrome scan, digital page 72
Direct image of printed p. 46, checked visually. It confirms the colon between the two lines of Snow’s couplet. Use S26 for the full chapter.
Compiled and published September 1994, Knowledge, pp. 34–38
This transcription leads to the unsigned Millennial Star article, S89. Kraut is its compiler, not its 1852 author.
Millennial Star 14, no. 25 (August 14, 1852), pp. 385–387, especially p. 386 (PDF p. 2)
The original periodical identifies the earlier newspaper. Page 386 explicitly connects God’s former manhood and progression. The text has no personal byline.
Online edition, no verified publication date; preface and ch. 2, The Great Announcement, p. 12 onward
Kraut argues for an identification of Adam and God while acknowledging the Church’s rejection of that teaching. S65 and S92 document the contrasting official and historical statements.
Vol. 2, no. 7 (February 7, 1852), p. 26; University of Utah digital newspaper facsimile
Earlier printing of the argument later headed Knowledge in S89. Matching text and the reprint attribution establish the relationship; neither supplies a personal byline.
Journal of Discourses 1:46–53, especially p. 50, passage about Adam in Eden
Young identifies Adam with the father and God in this passage. Read with S65 for Kimball’s later explicit rejection and S90 for Kraut’s interpretation.
Improvement Era, August 1916, pp. 934–942; Ensign reprint, April 2002
Explains why Jesus, Jehovah, can be called Father in several scriptural senses while remaining the Son of Elohim. A useful guide to the identity of the subject of historical statements.
September 23, 1995, paragraphs 2–3
Locates the divine destiny of sons and daughters in their relationship to heavenly parents; describes progression toward perfection and eternal life.
October 2023 general conference, discussion of the highest celestial glory and the family proclamation
Quotes section 76 regarding godhood, explicitly includes daughters, and describes exaltation through the Father’s plan and the Atonement of Jesus Christ.
No sources match this search. Try a surname, a year, or a source number such as S15.
Keep reading offline
The original 33-page PDF includes the article and its full source register.